Welcome to the Coatesville Dems Blog

Public Corruption in Chester County, PA

I believe an unlikely mix of alleged drug trafficking related politicos and alleged white nationalist related politicos united to elect the infamous “Bloc of Four” in the abysmal voter turnout election of 2005. During their four year term the drug business was good again and white nationalists used Coatesville as an example on white supremacist websites like “Stormfront”. Strong community organization and support from law enforcement, in particular Chester County District Attorney Joseph W. Carroll has begun to turn our community around. The Chester County drug trafficking that I believe centers on Coatesville continues and I believe we still have public officials in place that profit from the drug sales. But the people here are amazing and continue to work against the odds to make Coatesville a good place to live.

Tuesday, December 6, 2022

We worried about cyber attacks on power grids by foreign countries. Turns out all you need to cause a massive power grid failure is a rifle. I think the attack on the Moore County North Carolina power grid is a trial run.


"The center is not holding in America right now. As I noted on these pages last week, an armed and agitated right-wing movement is lashing out more boldly and sometimes more violently because of perceived losses in the nation’s “culture war” and very real losses at the ballot box. And the biggest loser of all is egging them on with increasingly unhinged statements from Mar-a-Lago. Experts properly call those urgings stochastic terrorism, but increasingly these feel like that Civil War — albeit a sporadic and asymmetrical one — we’ve been dreading."

 

Maybe 1/2 of the Coatesville Dems blog is about political corruption in Chester County PA. The other half is from what I perceive to be a growing threat from right wing domestic terrorists that I first noted in 2008.

For a long time I thought I was one of a few people such as historians of the right wing howling in the wind about the domestic terrorists egged on by Trump. See:

Wednesday, November 23, 2022

The White nationalist assault rifle strapped evangelicals didn’t get their “red wave” political solution. So it’s back to violent overthrow of government.



Will Bunch gets it


"A N.C. terror attack and Trump renouncing the Constitution: The new Civil War is here


This much seems clear: More than 161 years after the first cannonball sailed over Fort Sumter, an American Civil War has again come to the Carolinas. A strange, asymmetrical Civil War, to be sure, and one that has confounded the public and mainstream journalists — who seem confused over how to cover the news out of Moore County — as much as the sheriffs and the feds.

Indeed, a terror attack on the U.S. power grid — which has been long feared from Russian or Chinese hackers, but instead apparently came from some yahoos with AR-15s — seemed to epitomize one of the strangest American moments I’ve ever lived through. Things in the body politic are getting so surreal it’s hard to know what is tragedy and what is farce.

Around the time the shots were ringing out through the piney woods of Moore County, the public spectacle of the world’s richest man, Elon Musk, burning $44 billion of his vast wealth not so much to own Twitter, the social-media site so critical for sharing political ideas, but to use his new toy to “own the libs,” took a new turn. Musk used his now-ownership of Twitter’s internal files and his friendship with bro-dude journalist Matt Taibbi to gin up a faux scandal over alleged biased treatment in favor of troubled presidential son Hunter Biden. Most of Taibbi’s findings were over-caffeinated, except for the points that were dead wrong.

The nothingburger that Musk and Taibbi cooked up as the (all-caps!) TWITTER FILES did hit home in maybe the one place it was targeting most: Mar-a-Lago. For Donald Trump — 45th president of the United States, and the GOP 2024 frontrunner to become 47th and apparently last POTUS — the TWITTER FILES were the paper-thin excuse he needed to go where he’s been itching to reach for years: the end of American democracy.

“A massive Fraud of this type and magnitude allows for the termination of all rules, regulations, and articles, even those found in the Constitution,” Trump wrote on Saturday night, arguing that the inconsequential Taibbi/Musk report somehow rose to a level that President Joe Biden’s 2020 election must be undone in order to reinstall Trump as a supreme leader.

To steal Musk’s favorite phrase, let that sink in. Say the key words slowly. “Termination ... of ... the ... Constitution.”

And yet for the key folks in the American body politic, this hasn’t sunk in. The same so-called leaders of the Republican Party — who fell mute in the bloody aftermath of the attempted coup on Jan. 6, 2021 and more recently when Trump talked turkey on Thanksgiving with a Hitler-admiring antisemitic hip-hop superstar and America’s most vocal Holocaust denier — once again swallowed their tongues as the 2024 frontrunner made totalitarianism his main 2024 campaign promise. A mainstream media that seems to have only two gears — low, and Hillary’s emails — struggled to pull out of the muck of the latest Mar-a-Lago mudslide.

Look, I do understand the dilemma. The Beltway crowd is engaged in magical thinking that all the bat-guano crazy stuff happening out there in the heartland, punctuated by Trump’s battle cry for dictatorship, is only the last throes of a warped and wounded movement that may breathe its dying breath before the first 2024 primary votes are cast. After all, Trump’s meltdown comes as the walls of criminal prosecution — from new federal special prosecutor Jack Smith, not to mention Georgia and New York — are closing in. But also the second possibility — that Trump’s words were the declaration of a second American Civil War that will be embraced by far too many of the more than 74 million Americans who voted for him in 2020 — may be too frightening for elites to contemplate.

The problem is that too many foot soldiers are already waging this Civil War for basically the same reason that Southern states seceded in 1861: A coastal majority that didn’t share their values was threatening their “way of life,” whether that meant an economy based on chattel slavery, or social hierarchies based on prejudice and homophobia.

In Moore County, N.C. — about halfway between Mar-a-Lago and the White House — the terror attack on the power grid happened about an hour into the Downtown Divas drag show at the Sunrise Theater in the community of Southern Pines. Right-wing activists were protesting the event, and online speculation that the terror attack was to shut down the production spiked after one leading drag-show opponent — Emily Rainey, who lost her Army commission after attending Trump’s Jan. 6, 2021, rally — posted at the start of the blackout: “The power is out in Moore County, and I know why.”

Sheriff Fields told reporters that deputies did visit Rainey’s home after the attack and had “a word of prayer with her, but it turned out to be nothing.” But while the possible drag show/terror link is still under investigation in North Carolina, it should be noted it happened in the same day that assault-weapon-toting members of the right-wing Patriot Front shut down a planned drag story-time event at a church in Columbus, Ohio, as nearby members of White Lives Matter Ohio flashed Nazi salutes to passing cars. And also that the night before that, a man was arrested outside one of the Detroit area’s largest synagogues for shouting antisemitic threats at Jewish families dropping off kids for day care.

The center is not holding in America right now. As I noted on these pages last week, an armed and agitated right-wing movement is lashing out more boldly and sometimes more violently because of perceived losses in the nation’s “culture war” and very real losses at the ballot box. And the biggest loser of all is egging them on with increasingly unhinged statements from Mar-a-Lago. Experts properly call those urgings stochastic terrorism, but increasingly these feel like that Civil War — albeit a sporadic and asymmetrical one — we’ve been dreading.

We need to treat domestic terrorism on U.S. soil as seriously as we treated the 9/11 attacks, and to take Donald Trump’s dictatorial pronouncements as seriously as those that echoed across Europe in the 1930s. An attack on the power grid should be front-page news, not treated as a quirky right-wing fringe festival. And it’s long past time to end the deference that Trump is receiving as an ex-president and begin prosecuting him for his failed coup and multiple other crimes and misdemeanors. The Civil War is here, and the good guys will lose if they don’t fight back with everything they have."

MORE AT:

Philadelphia Inquirer

First shots of a U.S. Civil War fired in the Carolinas … again | Will Bunch Newsletter

Plus, the scoop on Josh Shapiro’s terrible, not good, transition team.

Will Bunch


CNN gets it


“A Department of Homeland Security Bulletin reported by CNN just days before the attack on a North Carolina substation indicated there was a heightened threat posed by domestic violent extremists in the United States against targets including critical infrastructure.

On Nov. 30, DHS renewed a national bulletin warning that lone offenders and small groups motivated by a range of ideological beliefs and personal grievances pose a lethal threat to the United States.

The advisory said in part “DHS maintained that potential targets include but are not limited to public gatherings, faith-based institutions, the LGBTQIA+ community, schools, racial and religious minorities, government facilities and personnel, US critical infrastructure, the media and perceived ideological opponents."

The electric grid has been described as an “attractive target” for domestic violent extremists in US, CNN reported earlier this year, citing an intelligence report.

In 2020 intelligence analysts saw major uptick in online chatter focused on attacking the Power Grid.

Notably in 2020, a 14-page document released in a Telegram channel favored by accelerationist groups seeking to speed the overthrow of the US government featured a White supremacist instruction guide to low-tech attacks meant to bring chaos, including how to attack a power grid with guns.

The document has been cited by Department of Homeland officials and was obtained by CNN.

“The powergrid would be crippled for a very large area. Armor piercing rounds shot into the transformers would destroy them,” the colorful how-to describes.

The writer goes on to frame how massive blackouts would aide in the toppling of society which is a key accelerationist goal. 

“But with the power off, when the lights don’t come back on… all hell will break lose, making conditions desirable for our race to once again take back what is ours,” the document reads.  

Several unique attempts to attack various grids have been cited by intelligence officials that analyze these specific threats. 

Investigators discovered a four-rotor drone July 16, 2020, in Pennsylvania recovered from the roof of a power station, according to a DHS Bulletin in Oct. 2021.

CNN reported earlier this year that in May 2020, three people claiming to be Boogaloo adherents allegedly conspired to attack an electrical substation in Las Vegas as part of an attempt to incite riots and violence amid demonstrations in the city. 

The suspects were charged with conspiracy to damage and destroy by fire and explosive and with possession of unregistered firearms.

The unsolved case of the attack on the Metcalf Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E) substation in Coyote, California, on April 16, 2013 set the bar for these types of attacks and has been a case study for intelligence officials

The vulnerabilities of the Power Grid have been closely examined by the Department of Energy, DHS and Congress.

According to the National Research Council, tasked by congress to examine these vulnerabilities, the US grid consists of:

  1. 6,400 power plants
  2. 55,000 substations
  3. 450,000 miles of transmission lines
  4. 3,000 companies

CNN's Geneva Sands, Whitney Wild and Kristina Sgueglia contributed to this report”


FROM:

3:05 p.m. ET, December 5, 2022

DHS bulletin indicated a heightened threat posed by domestic extremists days before grid attack

From CNN's John Miller


Tuesday, November 29, 2022

Herschel Walker obviously lives in Texas & uses his former wife's address to run in Georgia. Local officials not living where they claim to isn't obvious. In Pennsylvania removing a public official that doesn't live where he's says is a long & costly slog.

Maybe the most important sentences in my posts are these:

Clark was not on the ticket but ran an extensive and expensive write in campaign. He got very few votes. But that is not the issue. I believe there are several people holding or that have held public offices in Coatesville that do not live here. No one challenges them because they understand the possibility of winning in court is almost non-existent. I believe that there are many people holding public offices all across Chester County that do not live where they claim to live. 

Joe Carroll’s action could set a president for future efforts to remove persons that are allegedly illegally holding office. I believe that every instance of claiming to live where you do not is an instance of public corruption.* It is very hard to set a price on that kind of public corruption but I believe the cost to the public is in the millions of dollars.

* A man lived near West Chester, PA with his family & owned property in Coatesville PA. He served on commissions & redevelopment authority. He didn't live here but served the City of Coatesville well. 

***


"When he launched his campaign for U.S. Senate in Georgia, Herschel Walker claimed his deep roots in the state didn’t end with his days as a football legend at the University of Georgia.

It was widely known at the time that the Republican hopeful had been living in Texas for decades, though he has claimed to maintain a residence in Atlanta for “17 years.” Less widely known, however, was that Walker’s wife collected tens of thousands of dollars in rental income for that residence, according to his 2021 financial disclosure forms.

Advertisement

The house doubled as the Walker campaign’s first official address when he launched his bid in August 2021. Fulton County tax and property records show the home is solely owned by Walker’s wife, Julie Blanchard, who also collected rental income from 2020 and 2021 ranging from $15,000 to $50,000, according to the disclosure—defining the asset as “Georgia residence.”

Blanchard’s company also received a previously unreported $49,997 in COVID relief loans over that same period, at Walker’s Texas address, according to federal data. On one since-revised financial disclosure, Walker claimed the company had generated rental income for Blanchard, suggesting the company had an operational stake in the Atlanta property."

MORE AT:

DailyBeast

Republican Senate Candidate Herschel Walker Only Recently Stopped Renting Out Georgia ‘Home’


***




Wednesday, August 5, 2009

New comment about Residency of W Vincent Supervisor Barry DiLiberto

I received another comment today about my post:

Concerning the residency case in West Vincent Supervisor Barry DiLibero: 
Married politicos share a residency problem
Published: Monday, July 20, 2009
http://coatesvilledems.blogspot.com/2009/07/concerning-residency-case-in-west.html


Also see:
Friday, July 31, 2009
I am posting this for District Attorney Joe Carroll. 
For some reason his comment to did not go through. It is in reference to my posting "Concerning the residency case in West Vincent Supervisor Barry DiLibero"
Married politicos share a residency problem. 
http://coatesvilledems.blogspot.com/2009/07/i-am-posting-this-for-district-attorney.html

Today I received this comment:

"Anonymous said... 
Jim,
Next time you are talking to Joe Carroll...could you ask him how much this case is costing the taxpayers?

I find it hard to believe that it takes this long to determine residency. It seems that it should be easy to ascertain. Does he meet the residency requirement or not?

Should we really have expected Mr. Dilibero or Voters Services to do over a years worth of research and study case law to find a case from the 1950's to cite, that say's a man's residency is determined by his wife's. Are they asking us to believe that married people cannot live apart? I surely hope not!

So while you are at it, ask Joe why this is taking so long!"
August 5, 2009 8:37 AM 


My answer:

Unless the person involved acquiesces, it is a near impossibility to successfully challenge residency for political purposes. 

One example is the residency of James Clark. He ran and possibly still is running for District Justice in Coatesville’s District Court 15-1-03. The residency requirements for Coatesville’s District Court 15-1-03 is in part of Coatesville and South Coatesville. Mr. Clark lives in Thorndale. In a court document in Chester County President Judge Ott’s court Clark gives his address as 3401 Sylvan Dr., Thorndale, PA 19372. He claims a rental property in Coatesville as his address. 

Below are my notes from a hearing in Judge Ott’s courtroom on Friday April 20, 2009:

“I thought that Democratic Attorney John Carnes presented overwhelming evidence including several court documents and Clark’s drivers license that Magistrate Judge candidate James Clark lives in Thorndale. Clark had two relatives that claimed he lived at the address in Coatesville’s Second Ward that he listed on his petition. Clark said that even though a court document from October has Thorndale as his residence and driver’s license residence as Thorndale, he lives in Coatesville. 

I understood Clark to have said that his driver’s license and his court documents residence is really his business address and his real residence is in Coatesville. Hmmm.  

Even at the place he said he lives in Coatesville, he was only there a few months. State Law says that candidates for Magistrate Judge needs to reside at least a year at the residence on the ballot. The proceedings concerning James Clark were a little confusing to me but I believe that one of Clark’s relatives who is a Republican collected most of his signatures on both Republican and Democratic sides. Clark might not be on the ticket for multiple reasons. 

I wondered why Andrew Lehr was sitting right in front of me in the first spectator row. I found out when Lehr conferred with Clark and a woman named as his daughter, Shania London in the hallway. Is Clark a spoiler to Greg Hines? Lehr left when Clarks hearing was over.” 


 

See Clark’s court document here:
https://app.box.com/s/3j6ljb9zgfemsk83cqxr

Clark was not on the ticket but ran an extensive and expensive write in campaign. He got very few votes. But that is not the issue. I believe there are several people holding or that have held public offices in Coatesville that do not live here. No one challenges them because they understand the possibility of winning in court is almost non-existent. I believe that there are many people holding public offices all across Chester County that do not live where they claim to live. 

Joe Carroll’s action could set a president for future efforts to remove persons that are allegedly illegally holding office. I believe that every instance of claiming to live where you do not is an instance of public corruption. It is very hard to set a price on that kind of public corruption but I believe the cost to the public is in the millions of dollars.

Wednesday, November 23, 2022

The White nationalist assault rifle strapped evangelicals didn’t get their “red wave” political solution. So it’s back to violent overthrow of government.








“The Oath Keepers’ compulsive chatter about “civil war” did not represent the “ranting and raving of old men at a barber shop,” but the “real” and “sincere” planning of extremists committed to stopping the lawful transfer of power, a prosecutor told jurors during the seditious conspiracy trial’s closing  arguments.

Quoting liberally from the messages of Oath Keepers founder Stewart Rhodes and his four accused co-conspirators, Assistant U.S. Attorney Kathryn Rakoczy opened her closing arguments with their leader’s words on Nov. 5, 2020, merely two days after Election Day.

“We are not getting through this without a civil war,” Rhodes wrote. “Prepare your mind body and spirit.”

Major media outlets had not yet called President Joe Biden’s victory and wouldn’t do so for two more days. The thoughts of Oath Keeper Kelly Meggs, who would ultimately become the Florida chapter leader, turned to violence even earlier.

“I’m gonna go on a killing spree,” wrote Oath Keepers Florida chapter leader Kelly Meggs on the evening of Election Day itself. “Pelosi first.”

Throughout U.S. history, there have been bitterly contested elections, but they typically end with the loser respecting the peaceful transfer of power. That’s not what the Oath Keepers did, the prosecutor noted.

The day that it became clear the Donald Trump lost reelection on Nov. 7, 2020, Rhodes started talking to his Oath Keepers about the “Serbian plan,” a model that included storming the seat of government. Throughout the trial, prosecutors outlined the plan with internal communications from the Oath Keepers from the encrypted app Signal, the video app GoToMeeting, the walkie-talkie app Zello, and reams of heated social media communications.

One of the men privy to the GoToMeeting huddles was government witness Abdullah Rasheed, who said what he heard alarmed him.

“It sounded like we were going to war with — we were going to overthrow the United States government and start shooting everybody,” Rasheed said, adding that this made him hit record.

Other Oath Keepers members weren’t terrified; they were amped up, the prosecutor noted.

“This is the moment we’ve been waiting for,” Oath Keeper Jessica Watkins wrote…

Another defendant, Kenneth Harrelson, deleted most of the messages from his phone.

Oath Keepers associate Thomas Caldwell allegedly helped lead so-called quick reaction force, which gathered at a Comfort Inn in Alexandria, Va., with large numbers of firearms. Prosecutors say that the QRF, as it was known, planned to ferry those weapons by boat over the Potomac River if necessary, and that Caldwell’s own messages quoting Henry Wadsworth Longfellow reflect this.

“1 if by land,” Meggs wrote in the groups Signal channel, quoting Longfellow’s 1861 poem Paul Revere’s Ride. “2 if by sea...”


Indeed, on Jan. 6th itself, Rhodes wrote a message that he believed the breach of the Capitol was only a step: “They didn’t fire on them, but they street fought. That’s were we are now. Next comes our ‘Lexington.'”

Unpacking that quotation, the prosecutor noted that it suggested that Rhodes didn’t view Jan. 6th as the opening shot of the revolution — but a step toward it.

This is a developing story.

Have a tip we should know? tips@lawandcrime.com"

MORE AT:

Law & Crime


Oath Keepers Trial: Feds Note Civil War Chatter in Closings

Adam Klasfeld Nov 18th, 2022, 10:46 am




Monday, November 21, 2022

CLUB Q SHOOTING I'm 79. I look at obituaries first when trying to contact old friends. "when something happens, it’s like the polite thing to do is to make sure my friend isn’t dead.” Only idiots can't see the connections to 1938.

Only idiots can't see the connections to 1938:


 



"Already this year, armed protesters and right-wing groups such as the Proud Boys have used intimidating tactics to disrupt drag-related events in Texas, Nevada and Oregon, as well as other states. Children’s hospitals across the United States are facing growing threats of violence, including bomb threats, driven by an online anti-LGBTQ campaign attacking the facilities for providing care to transgender kids and teens. And in October, a man attacked a transgender librarian in Idaho before yelling homophobic slurs and attempting to hit two women with his car. Idaho is one of 18 states that does not have hate crime protections for LGBTQ people, though many local law enforcement agencies still track those crimes."

"Later, at a vigil for the victims at All Souls Unitarian Universalist Church, Taylor Oliver, 29, one of the attendees said, “These tragedies are causing people in the LGBT community to develop a habit of checking in on their friends. There’s almost an etiquette to checking in with your friends. Every single one of my friends, in other countries too, when something happens, it’s like the polite thing to do is to make sure my friend isn’t dead.”

Jessie Entwistle, of Colorado Springs, who was also at the vigil said he was in Orlando not long after the 2016 massacre at the Pulse night club, “so this all feels very familiar in a really sad way.”

“It feels like, ‘When is it going to happen to me?’ As opposed to thinking, ‘This kind of thing will never touch me.’ ”


MORE AT:

Washington Post

Right-wing demonstrators have increasingly mobilized over the past year against the LGBTQ community, experts say

November 20, 2022 at 6:19 p.m. EST 




https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
File:Una_giornata_particolare).jpg

On May 4, 1938, the day Hitler visits Mussolini in Rome, Antonietta, a naïve, sentimental and overworked homemaker, stays home doing her usual domestic tasks, while her fascisthusband, Emanuele, and their six spoiled children take to the streets to follow a parade. The building is empty, except for the caretaker and a neighbor across the complex, a charming man named Gabriele. He is a radio broadcaster who has been dismissed from his job and is about to be deported to Sardiniabecause of his homosexuality and alleged anti-fascist stance. After the family's myna escapes from their apartment and flies outside Gabriele's window, Antonietta shows up at his door, asking to be let in to reach the bird. Gabriele has been interrupted from attempting suicide, but helps rescue the myna by offering it food, and is amused by the episode. Antonietta is surprised by his demeanor and, unaware of his sexual orientation, flirts and dances the rumbawith him.

Despite their differences, they warm to each other. The caretaker warns Antonietta that Gabriele is an anti-fascist, which Antonietta finds despicable. Gabriele eventually opens up, confessing he was fired because he is a homosexual. Antonietta confides in him her troubles with her arrogant and unfaithful husband; who, she says, has shown a preference for an educated woman. Throughout their interaction and conversation, each realize that the other is oppressed by social and governmental conditioning and come to form a new impression than the one they first drew from one another. As a result, they have sex, but for different reasons. Gabriele explains that this changes nothing; as does Antonietta. (However, later, when her son reminds his mother of all the newspaper clippings she will have from the parade for her album collection, Antonietta's face reveals a look of slight indifference.) Soon after their intimate encounter, Antonietta's family comes back home and Gabriele is arrested. At the end, Antonietta sits near the window and starts reading a book Gabriele has given to her (The Three Musketeers). She watches as her lover leaves the complex, escorted by fascist policemen, before turning off the light and retiring to bed: Her husband is waiting there for her in order to beget their seventh child, whom he wants to name Adolfo.

MORE AT:


***

"Vincent James agrees with fellow white nationalist Nick Fuentes that this nation must be taken over by a right-wing dictatorship so that America First fascists can “force society into believing what we believe.” 

FROM:

Right Wing Watch

Right Wing Bonus Tracks: The Anointed Man of God 

Sunday, November 20, 2022

U.S. Government Quietly Declassifies Post-9/11 Interview With Bush and Cheney & FORESIGHT-AND HINDSIGHT National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States

 "Blair allegedly told Bush that if the president had said “before 9/11 that he wanted to put forces in Afghanistan, he — Blair — would have been floored. ‘I would have looked at you like a nut,’ Blair said. There was an appetite for a ‘throat slit’ (killing Bin Ladin), not a war footing.” With no apparent sense of the lethal irony present, Bush told the commissioners, “A president can’t force preemptive war without a cause. The country didn’t like war. ‘I don’t like it either,’ the President said.”

MORE AT:

THE INTERCEPT

U.S. Government Quietly Declassifies Post-9/11 Interview With Bush and Cheney

In a newly declassified interview conducted in 2004, Bush shows not a glimmer of awareness of the destruction and carnage he had unleashed on the world.


***

"Considering what was not done suggests possible ways to institutionalize imagination. To return to the four elements of analysis just mentioned:

  1. The CTC did not analyze how an aircraft, hijacked or explosives-laden, might be used as a weapon. It did not perform this kind of analysis from the enemy's perspective ("red team" analysis), even though suicide terrorism had become a principal tactic of Middle Eastern terrorists. If it had done so, we believe such an analysis would soon have spotlighted a critical constraint for the terrorists-finding a suicide operative able to fly large jet aircraft.They had never done so before 9/11.
  2. The CTC did not develop a set of telltale indicators for this method of attack. For example, one such indicator might be the discovery of possible terrorists pursuing flight training to fly large jet aircraft, or seeking to buy advanced flight simulators.
  3. The CTC did not propose, and the intelligence community collection management process did not set, requirements to monitor such telltale indicators.Therefore the warning system was not looking for information such as the July 2001 FBI report of potential terrorist interest in various kinds of aircraft training in Arizona, or the August 2001 arrest of Zacarias Moussaoui because of his suspicious behavior in a Minnesota flight school. In late August, the Moussaoui arrest was briefed to the DCI and other top CIA officials under the heading "Islamic Extremist Learns to Fly."24 Because the system was not tuned to comprehend the potential significance of this information, the news had no effect on warning.
  4. Neither the intelligence community nor aviation security experts analyzed systemic defenses within an aircraft or against terrorist-controlled aircraft, suicidal or otherwise. The many threat reports mentioning aircraft were passed to the FAA.While that agency continued to react to specific, credible threats, it did not try to perform the broader warning functions we describe here. No one in the government was taking on that role for domestic vulnerabilities.

    Richard Clarke told us that he was concerned about the danger posed by aircraft in the context of protecting the Atlanta Olympics of 1996, the White House complex, and the 2001 G-8 summit in Genoa. But he attributed his awareness more to Tom Clancy novels than to warnings from the intelligence community. He did not, or could not, press the government to work on the systemic issues of how to strengthen the layered security defenses to protect aircraft against hijackings or put the adequacy of air defenses against suicide hijackers on the national policy agenda.

The methods for detecting and then warning of surprise attack that the U.S. government had so painstakingly developed in the decades after Pearl Harbor did not fail; instead, they were not really tried. They were not employed to analyze the enemy that, as the twentieth century closed, was most likely to launch a surprise attack directly against the United States."

MORE AT:

National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States

FORESIGHT-AND HINDSIGHT